Long before anyone thought to write them down, British tales were told in kitchens, by fires, at harvest suppers and in the corner of a pub. A storytelling evening is that habit kept deliberately: a handful of people, a warm room, the lamps turned down, and one voice carrying a story across to the rest. It takes an afternoon to arrange and costs almost nothing. Here is how to do it properly.

Decide What Kind of Evening You Are Hosting

There are two natural shapes, and it pays to choose one before you invite anybody. The first is the kitchen-table evening: six to ten people, everyone in the telling, tales taken in turns, tea and cake in the middle. The second is the parlour evening: twelve to twenty-five people, two or three hosts who have prepared their stories in advance, and a proper interval. Both work. The kitchen version is easier to start and warmer; the parlour version gives you room to invite the friend who tells a really good ghost story.

Whichever you choose, tell guests what to expect when you invite them. "An hour and a half of stories, no phones, bring a cushion" is enough. People who arrive expecting a party behave differently from people who arrive expecting a story, and a room that settles quickly is worth more than any amount of preparation.

Choosing the Tales

A good evening is a set, not a list. Three or four tales is plenty for most gatherings; five short ones if your tellers are brisk. Aim for no more than an hour of actual telling in total, and remember that a tale takes longer aloud than it does in your head.

The kinds of tale that work aloud

• Local legends — the standing stone, the drowned village, the road where the headless coachman is meant to drive. These land hardest because they belong to a place your listeners know.
• Wonder tales and drolls — Jack and his tricks, youngest sons, three tasks, a bargain kept badly. Familiar bones, endlessly retellable.
• Ghost and bogie stories — short, single-idea tales with a chill on the last line. Best kept for the second half, when the room has gone quiet.
• Cumulative and chain tales — the pig that won't go over the stile, the house that Jack built. Superb openers: rhythmic, easy on the teller and quick to build a listening hush.

Where to find them

County folklore collections, published fairy-tale anthologies and older dialect collections are the usual hunting grounds, and most are cheap second-hand. Katharine Briggs, Ruth Tongue, Joseph Jacobs and Robert Chambers are reliable names to look for. Read the tale aloud before you commit to it; some stories that look wonderful on the page go flat in the mouth, and others surprise you.

Building the set

Open with something short and slightly light. Put your longest tale before the break, and your strongest at the end, where it will follow people home. Never bury your best story in the middle of the first half. If children are present, keep the genuinely frightening material for after they have gone up to bed.

Learning a Tale So It Stays With You

You do not need to memorise a story word for word, and trying to is the quickest way to sound stiff. Learn the bones and let the words happen on the night. Read the tale aloud twice, then write down five or six beats — the opening, three or four turnings, the ending. Learn the first line and the last line exactly; the middle will look after itself.

Hold on to the concrete details: the number of brothers, the colour of the horse, the name of the village. Fix each one to a picture in your head. Then tell it to a wall, to a friend, or to the washing-up, twice more. Nobody in the audience has a script, so there is nothing to get wrong.

Setting the Room

Light is the whole trick. Turn off the overhead bulb, put on two or three lamps, and add candles if you have them. You want light on faces and dimness behind the teller. Sit people in a circle or a horseshoe rather than in rows; the teller should be in the ring, not in front of it, even if they stand to speak.

Open a window before guests arrive so the room is fresh, then close it. Silence phones properly — not on the table, away. Keep music for the arrival and the interval, never under a tale. A single candle, a bowl of apples or a decent fire is atmosphere enough; costumes and props push an evening from warm into theatrical.

Food, Drink and the Shape of the Night

Keep the food plain and room-temperature. Bread and cheese with pickle, a fruit cake, parkin, shortbread or flapjack, a pot of tea, ale, cider, elderflower cordial, and a nip of something stronger for the end. Nothing that needs carving, timing or attention while you are meant to be listening.

1. Guests arrive; drinks and talk for twenty minutes or so.
2. A short welcome: what the evening is, no phones, no need to applaud.
3. First half — two or three tales, twenty-five to thirty minutes.
4. Interval of twenty minutes, with food and refills.
5. Second half — one longer tale, or a pair of short ones.
6. A brief goodbye verse or blessing, thanks, and let people drift when they want to.

The Host's Job While the Stories Are Being Told

Your work is mostly invisible. Introduce each teller in one sentence — a name is enough, save the biography. Sit slightly outside the circle so you can watch the room and keep an eye on the clock without visibly doing either.

Above all, do not rescue pauses. A moment of silence after a story is not a failure; it is the audience finishing the tale in their own heads. Count to five before you speak. If someone starts a long anecdote of their own, thank them warmly and say you will come back to it in the interval, then move on.

Traditional openings and closings do a lot of work here. "Once upon a time" has cousins all over Britain — "Once there was, and once there wasn't" is one, and different counties have their own. Hear what your tellers use, borrow what you like, and use the same closing line each time if it helps mark the end of a tale.

Make It a Habit

A regular small evening beats an occasional grand one every time. Pick a night — the first Thursday of the month, say — and keep it, even when only four people turn up. Rotate who hosts and who tells. Encourage newcomers to try one short story rather than a long one, and keep a notebook of tales you have heard and want to learn.

Before everyone leaves, name the next date. That single sentence is what turns an evening into a tradition.

Photo: Haley Bee / Pexels